This is one of those
childrens books that is eminently suitable for adult readers of fantasy. It is the
sequel to The Forbidden Library and in my opinion, is quite probably the
better book certainly in terms of structure, and is possibly even more imaginative.
One of the old Readers, Esau-of-the-Waters, is dead, something which
simply does not happen naturally. Murder is suspected, and the likely culprit is his
apprentice, Jacob. As is the custom, a group of other apprentices are sent to Esaus
realm to find out what happened and to bring Jacob to justice. Alice isnt entirely
unhappy about being included, since she might find clues as to what happened to her lost
father. But it soon becomes evident that something in Esaus realm is intent on
killing the apprentices. Dont ask me why, but I was reminded of Elder Scrolls:
Oblivion. All those towers. And as for the apprentice, yes, it does appear he is indeed
quite mad.
I would not give this book to a child prone to nightmares, there is too
much here to feed bad dreams, but otherwise its a fun read for fantasy-lovers of all
ages.